Receiving an OSHA Citation and Notification of Penalty is not the end of the enforcement process — it is the beginning of a decision window that determines the outcome. Employers who understand what options are available, what deadlines govern those options, and what the informal conference process actually involves are in a fundamentally different position than employers who react without preparation.
This article explains what happens after a citation is issued, with a focus on the informal conference — the primary administrative mechanism through which citation items, violation classifications, and proposed penalties can be addressed before the matter becomes a final order.
The 15-Working-Day Contest Period
When OSHA issues a citation, the employer has 15 working days from receipt to take action. This is not 15 calendar days — weekends and federal holidays are excluded. Within that window, the employer has three options:
- Request an informal conference with the OSHA Area Director to discuss the citation, proposed penalties, and abatement requirements.
- File a written notice of contest to formally challenge the citation before the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission (OSHRC).
- Take no action, in which case the citation becomes a final order of the Review Commission — unappealable and fully enforceable, including all penalties and abatement obligations.
This deadline is absolute. There is no extension, no grace period, and no mechanism to reopen a citation that has become a final order due to a missed deadline. Employers must calendar this date immediately upon receipt of the citation package.
One point that catches employers off guard: requesting an informal conference does not stay or pause the 15-working-day contest period. The clock continues to run. If settlement is not reached during the informal conference, the employer must still file a notice of contest within the original 15-working-day window or lose the right to challenge the citation.
What Is an Informal Conference?
An informal conference is an administrative meeting conducted by the OSHA Area Director or Assistant Area Director under 29 CFR 1903.20. It is the employer’s opportunity to discuss any issue raised by the inspection, citation, notice of proposed penalty, or notice of intention to contest.
Informal conferences may be conducted in person at the OSHA Area Office, by telephone, or by video conference. They are not adversarial hearings — there is no judge, no sworn testimony, and no formal rules of evidence. They are, however, structured proceedings with defined participants, mandatory discussion items, and real enforcement consequences.
Who Requests an Informal Conference
The employer may request an informal conference under 29 CFR 1903.20. The conference is conducted by the Area Director or Assistant Area Director at the OSHA Area Office.
What the Area Director Can Do
The Area Director’s authority during an informal conference is broader than many employers realize. The Area Director has the ability to make adjustments to the citation — including the violations, the penalties, and the abatement requirements — and to formalize any resolution through an Informal Settlement Agreement (ISA). Employers who come to the conference prepared to present relevant facts and documentation are in a position to have a substantive discussion about the citation. Employers who do not are limited to accepting what is offered.
What Gets Discussed
OSHA requires that certain topics be addressed during every informal conference. These mandatory discussion items include:
- Whether the citation package has been posted as required (if it has not, the conference may be postponed until posting is confirmed)
- The purpose of the conference
- Contest rights and deadlines
- The reason the inspection was conducted
- The rights of the participants
- Each citation item, including abatement requirements and abatement certification
At the conclusion of the conference, the Area Director will summarize the primary issues discussed and any potential actions, and document that summary in the case file.
Informal Settlement Agreements
When a resolution is reached during or immediately following the informal conference, the result is formalized through an Informal Settlement Agreement. The ISA is prepared and signed by the employer, then countersigned by the Area Director. It is effective upon signature of both parties, and the documents must be dated on the actual day of signature.
All revisions to the agreement must be mutually agreed upon. If the employer inserts new language that substantially alters the negotiated terms and the Area Director deems the changes unacceptable, the employer’s signed agreement may be treated as a notice of contest rather than a settlement.
If Settlement Is Not Reached
If the informal conference does not result in a settlement and the employer files a notice of contest, the matter proceeds to formal litigation before the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission.
This is a significant transition. Once a case moves past the informal conference stage and into formal contest proceedings, the process becomes more complex, more time-consuming, and more resource-intensive for all parties.
Why This Matters
The informal conference is not a formality. It is a structured proceeding with defined authority, mandatory procedures, and binding outcomes. For employers who prepare thoroughly and present their position effectively, it offers a realistic path to resolving the matter favorably without further proceedings.
For employers who show up unprepared — without organized documentation, without a clear understanding of the citation items, and without a coherent position on each alleged violation — the informal conference becomes a missed opportunity that cannot be recovered.
Construction employers facing OSHA citations or preparing for an informal conference can contact AWSEC for enforcement representation grounded in direct experience managing these proceedings from the agency side.
AWSEC LLC provides OSHA enforcement representation, compliance audits, safety program development, and technical training for construction employers throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. Founded by a former OSHA Assistant Area Director with 16 years of federal enforcement experience. Contact AWSEC →