When an informal conference does not result in a settlement, the next step is for the employer to formally contest the citation and stand before the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission. This is a significant transition. The process moves from an administrative discussion with the OSHA Area Director to adjudicatory proceedings governed by statutory authority, formal rules of procedure, and shifting burdens of proof.
This article explains what happens after a notice of contest is filed, how the proceedings are structured, how violations are classified, and how penalties are reassessed— so that employers understand what the formal contest process involves before they are in the middle of it.
Filing the Notice of Contest
Under Section 10(a) of the OSH Act, an employer who receives a Citation and Notification of Penalty has 15 business days from receipt to file a written notice of contest with the OSHA Area Office. This deadline is the same window that governs informal conference requests, and it is absolute. If no notice of contest is filed and no informal settlement agreement is reached within that period, the citation and proposed penalties become a final order of the Review Commission — not subject to review by any court or agency.
The notice of contest must be in writing. It should identify the specific citation items, proposed penalties, or abatement requirements being contested. Filing it does not require legal representation at that stage, and it does not commit the employer to a particular defense — it preserves the right to a hearing.
The Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission
Once a notice of contest is filed, the case moves to the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission (OSHRC). This is an important distinction that many employers do not fully appreciate: OSHRC is an independent federal agency, entirely separate from OSHA and the Department of Labor. OSHA investigates, issues citations, and proposes penalties. OSHRC adjudicates contested cases. The two agencies operate independently of each other.
Under Section 12 of the OSH Act, OSHRC is composed of three members appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate. The Commission appoints Administrative Law Judges who hear contested cases and issue decisions. The Solicitor of Labor — not OSHA — represents the Secretary of Labor in formal contest proceedings.
How the Case Proceeds
When the employer files a notice of contest, the Secretary of Labor immediately advises the Commission. The Area Director transmits the notice of contest and related documents to OSHRC, and forwards the complete investigative file to the Regional Solicitor of Labor. Under the Commission’s Rules of Procedure, the Secretary is required to file a formal complaint with the Commission within 20 calendar days after receiving the employer’s notice of contest.
Once a notice of contest is filed and the case is within the jurisdiction of the Commission, the dynamic between the employer and OSHA changes. There are no further investigations of, or conferences with, the employer relating to any issues underlying the contested citations without prior clearance from the Regional Solicitor. All inquiries relating to the Citation and Notification of Penalty — from the employer, employee representatives, attorneys, insurance carriers, or any other party — are referred to the Solicitor’s Office. The employer is no longer dealing with the Area Office.
Procedural Tracks
OSHRC operates under two procedural tracks. Conventional proceedings follow formal rules governing pleadings, discovery, motions, and evidentiary hearings. Simplified proceedings, governed by 29 C.F.R. Part 2200, Subpart M, apply to less complex cases — generally those with aggregate proposed penalties under $20,000, and at the discretion of the Chief Administrative Law Judge, some cases with penalties up to $30,000. Cases involving willful or repeat violations or fatalities are typically not designated for simplified proceedings. In simplified proceedings, formal pleadings are generally not required, and early discussion among the parties to narrow the disputed issues is expected.
Discovery
Regardless of which track applies, both parties have the opportunity to discover evidence in the possession of the opposing party. Discovery methods in Commission proceedings include requests for admissions, interrogatories, requests for production of documents, and depositions. The employer should expect to receive discovery requests from the Solicitor’s Office and should be prepared to respond within the deadlines established by the Commission’s rules. Failure to respond to prehearing scheduling orders or engage in the discovery process can result in sanctions, including dismissal of the notice of contest.
The Hearing
Upon assignment of the case, the Administrative Law Judge sets a hearing date and selects a location as close as practicable to where the alleged violations occurred. The hearing is an administrative trial conducted in accordance with the Commission’s Rules of Procedure (29 C.F.R. Part 2200).
The hearing involves a full examination of the evidence, including witness testimony, documentary evidence, and briefs submitted by both parties. Upon hearing all the evidence, the ALJ issues a written decision that includes findings of fact and conclusions of law. The Commission then issues a decision affirming, modifying, or vacating the citations and penalties proposed by OSHA.
One point that employers should understand: settlement is permitted at any stage of Commission proceedings. A case that has moved past the informal conference and into formal contest can still be resolved through a Formal Settlement Agreement approved by the ALJ. The fact that a notice of contest has been filed does not foreclose the possibility of a negotiated resolution.
Violation Classifications and What They Require
The classification assigned to a violation — serious, willful, or repeat — carries different penalty ranges and requires different levels of proof.
A serious violation exists if there is a substantial probability that death or serious physical harm could result from a condition which exists, or from one or more practices, means, methods, operations, or processes at the workplace unless the employer did not, and could not with the exercise of reasonable diligence, know of the presence of the violation.
A willful violation exists when an employer commits the violation with either intentional disregard or plain indifference to employee safety and health. Intentional disregard is established when the employer was aware of the applicable standard or regulation and was also aware of a workplace condition or practice in violation of those requirements, yet did not abate the hazard; or when the employer was not aware of the applicable standard or regulation, yet had knowledge of a comparable legal requirement (such as a state or local law) and was also aware of a workplace condition or practice in violation of that requirement. A willful citation can also be issued where an employer knows that specific steps must be taken to address a hazard, yet substitutes their own judgment in place of the requirements of the applicable standard.
A repeat violation requires the Secretary to establish that the current violation is the same or substantially similar to a prior violation for which a citation was previously issued.
How Penalties Are Reassessed
One of the most significant aspects of formal contest proceedings is the treatment of penalties. Upon the filing of a notice of contest, the penalties proposed by OSHA become advisory only. The Administrative Law Judge conducts an independent, de novo assessment of the appropriate penalty based on the facts of the case.
Under Section 17(j) of the OSH Act, the ALJ must give due consideration to four statutory criteria:
• The size of the employer’s business
• The gravity of the violation — assessed by the number of employees exposed, the duration of exposure, precautions taken, and the likelihood of injury. Gravity is the principal factor in penalty determination.
• The good faith of the employer — including the employer’s safety and health program, cooperation during the inspection, and corrective actions taken
• The employer’s history of previous violations
The ALJ has full discretion to assess a penalty that may be higher or lower than what OSHA originally proposed. The penalty determination starts fresh.
After the ALJ Decision
Under Section 12(j) of the OSH Act, the Administrative Law Judge’s decision becomes the final order of the Commission within 30 days — unless a Commission member directs that the decision be reviewed by the full Commission during that period. If Commission review is directed, the Commission conducts its own review of the evidence and briefs and issues an order that becomes the final order. Commission decisions, including ALJ decisions, are publicly available through the OSHRC website.
A party adversely affected by a final order of the Commission may seek judicial review in a United States Court of Appeals under Section 11 of the Act. The petition for review must be filed within 60 days following issuance of the Commission’s order. The court reviews the Commission’s findings of fact under a substantial evidence standard — it does not retry the case. If no petition for review is filed within that 60-day window, the Commission’s findings of fact and order become conclusive.
Enforcement of Final Orders
An employer’s obligation to abate a cited violation arises when there is a final order of the Commission upholding the citation. Under Section 11(b) of the OSH Act, the Secretary may obtain a summary enforcement order from the appropriate U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to enforce that final order. An employer who violates such a court order can be found in contempt of court. Potential sanctions for contempt include daily penalties, recovery of the Secretary’s costs, and other measures the court deems necessary to secure compliance.
Why This Matters
Formal contest proceedings are resource-intensive, procedurally demanding, and governed by rules that differ substantially from the informal conference process. Employers who understand the structure of these proceedings — what OSHRC is, how the case moves through the system, how penalties are reassessed, and what the timeline looks like — are in a fundamentally different position than employers who enter the process without preparation.
The documentation assembled during the inspection (Article 1 in this series) and organized for the informal conference (Article 2) forms the same evidentiary foundation that supports or undermines an employer’s position in formal proceedings. Employers who have maintained thorough records — safety programs, training documentation, inspection reports, corrective action records, and disciplinary documentation — have a stronger foundation from which to respond at every stage of the enforcement process.
Construction employers facing OSHA citations or evaluating whether to pursue formal contest proceedings can contact AWSEC for enforcement representation grounded in direct experience managing these cases from the agency side.
AWSEC LLC provides OSHA enforcement representation, compliance audits, safety program development, and technical training for construction employers throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. Founded by a former OSHA Assistant Area Director with 16 years of federal enforcement experience. Contact AWSEC →